In my previous post I talked a little about why a black and white version of a photo is sometimes preferable to the original colour version. Below is an example (click on the thumbnails to enlarge) and explanation of a few handy points to keep in mind in your own photography.
In this photo taken at my niece’s outdoor wedding, while the bride and her friends look quite lovely in colour, there is a lot of stuff going on around and behind them, some of it in strong primary colours. The result is a busy composition, which has the unwanted effect of robbing attention away from the three pretty faces in this impromptu portrait. While most photos benefit from a little cropping, in this case it would not eliminate the red lanterns above their heads, nor the blue tent awning. The middle woman’s yellow sash also interacts with the other colours, making them even more prominent. This is a classic case where converting to monochrome makes all the difference in the world, and combined with a little cropping, the shift in focus is directed to right where it needs to be – on their smiling faces.
I was asked today if my camera has a monochrome setting, and whether I use it. Yes it does, and no I don’t use it. Professionals suggest that you always shoot in colour, and make the decision later during post-editing. This makes sense because just as some photos are more impressive in black and white, others don’t work as well and actually NEED to be in colour. This is what I’ve been studying and practicing all summer, and the results have taken my work to a whole new level.
Questions to ask yourself when assessing a photo:
- What is the most important thing about this photo?
- What should be emphasized?
- What should be de-emphasized?
- Will cropping help to eliminate extraneous objects or people that are distracting from the intended subject of the photo?
- Am I following the rule of thirds?
- Are there simple colour harmonies enhancing the composition, or crazy random colours everywhere undermining the focal point and subject of the photo? (Note: sometimes it’s just one harsh colour off to the side that’s throwing everything off.)
- Would converting to monochrome make this photo really pop? Try it. If it’s not working, switch it back to colour.
Because my background is in fine art, and I’ve studied colour theory and the elements and principles of design, I know that it’s an advantage for me where photography and photo-editing are concerned. Still with a little knowledge, and a discriminating eye, anyone can aspire to make their photos the very best that they can be!
In closing, I would like to add that photographers using older, traditional materials and methods (developing photos in chemical baths in the darkroom) utilized many techniques to improve their final results. They played with contrast, dodged or burned areas in order to compensate for over or under-exposure, and had a variety of darkroom tricks to make their images great. Today’s professional photographers use photo-editing software (digital darkrooms) such as Adobe’s Lightroom or Apple’s Aperture to accomplish the same thing and more. The magic is indeed alive and well in today’s digital world, and I love it!
While this post has focused primarily on situational portraits, my previous post examines the monochrome landscape.
I would love to hear about your work, challenges, and triumphs in photography, so please feel free to leave a comment! ML
3 thoughts on “Tutorial: When to Choose Monochrome”
I’m your basic ‘point-and-click’ snapper, new to tweaking shots and interested in trying black and white. Funny, just this afternoon in two different places (magazine, and a book in the library in town) I read to shoot colours in RAW and tweak to B and W later … and now you~! Three times should confirm any issue, so I’ll do it. Thanks for that~!
You’re very welcome. I too have just started to embrace all that photography can be… beyond the click so to speak. I’ve been dabbling in B/W for years, but it was only this past week while working with the “landscape” shots from my niece’s wedding that I realized that some photos just don’t work in colour. The shots were sort of interesting, but sort of boring too. Converting them to monochrome and punching up the contrast… well, I gasped when I saw the results! Analyzing what the problem was has been an eye opener.
Having said that, some of Hipstamatic’s B/W settings (iPhone) are pretty dramatic, and you can capture some great, fun shots on the fly that way too. I posted a few examples here http://www.pinterest.com/milariviere/black-white/
Thanks again, and I’m looking forward to seeing your new endeavours! Enjoy!